Jake’s Dilemma is a vibrant sports bar located in the Upper West Side of NYC, offering a mix of an old school pub vibe and a downtown bar atmosphere. The venue features 19 different drafts and a wide selection of bottled beers, including craft and seasonal options.
Guests can enjoy an outdoor café, multiple beer pong tables, and the area’s only foosball table. The bar hosts trivia and live music during the week, while weekends feature a lively dance floor with a DJ.
Information sourced from restaurant website and may be subject to change.
Menu
Appetizer Sampler$25.99
Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, Fries, Mac N Cheese Wedges, and Cheese Quesadilla.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: No
Estimated Calorie Count: 214
Jake’s Quesadilla$15.99
Choice of Spiced Chicken, Beef, or Pork. Sautéed Peppers, Onions, and Cheddar Jack Blend. Salsa & Sour Cream on the Side.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 165
Veggie Quesadilla$12.99
Sautéed Peppers, Onions & Cheddar Jack Blend. Salsa & Sour Cream on the Side.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 165
Jake’s Nachos Grande$13.99
Cheddar Jack Blend, Black Bean, Pico De Gallo, and Jalapeño. Salsa & Sour Cream on the Side.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: No
Estimated Calorie Count: 180
Homemade Guacamole$11.99
Served with Chips & Salsa.
Allergens: None detected, Plant Based: Yes, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 210
Hot Dog$3.99
Add Fries or Tots for $1.99.
Allergens: None detected, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: No
Estimated Calorie Count: 300
Fries or Tots$7.99
Dietary/Allergen Info: None
Seasoned Fries or Tots$8.99
Dietary/Allergen Info: None
Sweet Potato Fries$7.99
Dietary/Allergen Info: None
Smothered Fries or Tots$10.99
Served with Cheddar Jack Cheese, Bacon, Jalapeños, and Sour Cream.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 400
Mozzarella Sticks$8.99
(6) Served with Marinara Sauce.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 600
Cauliflower Bites$11.99
Tossed in Mild, Medium, Hot, BBQ, Honey BBQ, Thai Chili, Jamaican Jerk, or Cajun Rub.
Allergens: None detected, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 400
Jalapeño Poppers$7.99
(6) Served with Sour Cream.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 350
Mac & Cheese Wedges$7.99
(6).
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 350
Old Fashioned Sliders$13.99
(3) American Cheese and Grilled Onion. Served with a Choice of Tots or Fries.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 360
Pulled Pork Sliders$13.99
(3) Slow Cooked Pulled Pork with Homemade BBQ Sauce Topped with Chipotle Apple Coleslaw. Comes with a choice of Fries or Tots.
Allergens: None detected, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 504
Chicken Fingers$13.99
Choice of Honey Mustard, Ranch, BBQ, or Blue Cheese.
Allergens: Milk/Dairy, Mustard, Plant Based: No, Gluten Free: No, Low Carb: Yes
Estimated Calorie Count: 350
Boneless Wings$13.99
Tossed in Mild, Medium, Hot, BBQ, Honey BBQ, Thai Chili, Jamaican Jerk, or Cajun Rub.
Menu Date: September 2025
Dietary & Allergen Information: Please be aware that our dish analysis is powered by AI and may contain errors. Always check with your server before ordering.
Discover New York City’s Vibrant Food Scene
New York City’s food culture is a melting pot of global influences, iconic street eats, and deli classics — with many restaurants offering multilingual menus to welcome visitors from everywhere. Must-try dishes include fresh bagels with lox, classic New York-style pizza slices, towering pastrami on rye sandwiches, creamy New York cheesecake, all-beef hot dogs, and diverse bites from dim sum to halal carts.
Want to go deeper into New York’s flavors, hidden gems, and tips for navigating local menus? Our full New York Food Scene Guide covers it all.
Experience New York City’s Flavors on a Guided Tour
Why not dive deeper into New York City’s incredible food scene with a guided food tour? Taste authentic bagels, pizza, deli sandwiches, global bites, and more at hidden, family-run spots — just like the ones you love in NYC.
Book a highly-rated tour with Devour Tours — popular options include the Greenwich Village Food Tour (bohemian neighborhood with Italian legacy, authentic family-run eateries, and diverse tastings) or the Lower East Side Historical Food Tour (iconic delis like Katz’s, immigrant history, pastrami, dumplings, and more in a culturally rich area).
Affiliate link — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Spotted an Error?
Please help us make things better and tell us whats wrong
⚠️ Dietary & Allergy Warning
Our AI estimates dietary info based on dish names and descriptions. Always inform your server of allergies or dietary restrictions before ordering.
Address
430 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA
GPS
40.7843586, -73.9777082
Telephone
Accuracy
This menu is as accurate as possible, but prices, availability, and ingredients are subject to change.
Please Help Us to Help Others by Uploading the Latest Menu here.
Notice: Unauthorized scraping, copying, or automated extraction of this content is strictly prohibited. Copyright © 2025 Barcelona Menus. All rights reserved.